I would really love an "undo" button


#1

Howdy.
I have just recently started this game, but I liked it enough to shell out for a lifetime membership.
There is one thing which keeps getting to me, granted its caused by my own carelessness.

I have the bad habit of clicking where I’m not supposed to. This is usually caused by my dog stepping on my tablet while I play. I would love the option to undo infrastructure upgrades.

Since everything is processed on the tick, I would hope its doable to have a little leeway to undo an action which only impacts one of your planets. Granted I would understand if it was too complicated to implement this for a real time game and would be just as happy if it was only available in turn based games.

Anyone else thing this would be a good improvement? Or am I crazy? :wink:
Irregardless, I am quite pleased with the game! Keep up the good work!
J.R.


Tweaks to create game options
Are You Sure?
#2

I’ll second this one. It would be nice to be able to undo something that hasn’t actually started to happen yet.


#3

Or if “undo” is too complex, a commit button would do too.


#4

“Submit changes/Cancel changes” button set? Automatically submitted if you close the window or a Tick progresses.


#5

This is on my list, but I think it might be a largish task. Thanks for the feedback that you really want it though. I might need to do is sooner rather than later.


#6

I’d love this. Just was trying to award a badge and gave the wrong one. :frowning:


#7

I gave two of the same to the same guy for not having a confirmation button…


#8

I’ve given techs to the enemy on a few occasions by accident.


Trading with the AI
#9

I added a confirmation for tech trading just the other week. I will do badges soon too.


#10

Yea, I saw the confirmation - that’s good stuff!


#11

I bought 5 science on the same star today which spent most of my money. I guess I had my finger on the touch pad too long. I blame Windows 10 but that is incredibly frustrating. It’s basically a wasted cycle.


#12

Hey there Stu! :smile:

I’ve had the above problems on my own computers, really annoying! If your touchpad has hardware buttons I would suggest disabling the tap-to-click functionality.

I find upgrading from the Galaxy screen to be safer. When you build from there it does a full map render between clicks (this is a performance bug). This artificially slows down the buying process making it harder to buy lots of stuff. It also keeps the sort order between purchases.

@JayKyburz Functionality to undo everything done this turn would be easier to add and still useful in the really bad cases.


#13

What about if we were to add a 5-10 second delay before any orders were dispatched to the server. That way you could cancel before they were sent to the server.

I added a full turn undo for Blight in single plater by just saving the game in the databse before you jump ahead in time


#14

If you’re thinking what I think your thinking, a client-side only solution, it’s not a bad idea. Though it may be better to allow choosing, under account settings, have it as it currently is or completely manual, a big shiny commit button, rather than have timers (the horror :scream: *). If you start involving client side timers causing server side changes you get stuff like sleeping laptops causing problems. *

Another option is to hold them in the session variables on the server, say pending-changes. A reset order would dump the pending-changes variable. This would mean pending-changes would need to be send down when the page is (re)loaded and integrated into the data.

* I’m biased


#15

haha, checkout np.onServerRequest at line 935 of game.js. The game already waits 5 seconds before sending some orders so that if you spam a bunch of upgraded on the galaxy screen, they get sent as one order.


#16


#17

What fay said!

Count me as a vote against timers.
Honestly, I don’t mind the way it is now. I’ve had my occasional derps and wasted turns, but all preventable. In each case, I felt I was being punished for bad play, not for an unfair disadvantage or fault in the game. Stay focused or bear the consequences.


#18

Undo would be great. I inadvertantly beefed up industry on the wrong star ( a star that was pending takeover by hostiles) when using my phone and it really sucked.


#19

It might be helpful if all ( or most or many ? ) user commands were temporarily stored into a buffer array on the server, and there was a UI button that allows the player to see the differences before and after. This could allow user to make corrections ? At the tick transition or turn jump, all orders are committed and the buffer is dumped to update to the server.

This is not the same quite thing as the time slider in Subtifuge, but allows the user to see one tick or turn jump into the future, and possibly make corrections.

This feature would not buffer emails or tech trades, because these directly interact with other players.

This could sound like a lot of work and changes for Jay to make.


#20

I too would vote against a timer - keep the game speedy. Just a “full undo” (as Jay has already implemented in Blight) would be adequate … then in the rare cases where you screw up, you just redo the build.